testtest

Discussion: Why You Don’t Need Hollow Points

"This is why smaller, or lower-powered, centerfire cartridges are best served by either FMJ or Lehigh-type projectiles."


Accurate shot placement will do the rest.



thing is...under duress or shear fear, can everyone put the shot where needed......100% of the time...???

i think not.

cuz if that were true......hitting the spot 100% of the time....then why do even the cops..."spray" shots all over the place"..???

we as ordinary citizens probably train more each week, than most cops, but that is still no guarantee......we can hit the target.
 
The manufacturers are always looking for the next 'big thing' to promote what will boost sales and make them money. Hollow points fall into that category.

People have tried various forms of hollow point all the way back to the days of the buffalo hunters. They never caught on, for whatever the reasons may be. Then along came SuperVel in the 70s, and all the other manufacturers tried again with a full court press. The rest is history, even though it took ~30 years to work out most of the kinks.

I've never thought that much of hollow points. I've not seen any evidence that they are to be preferred over a good soft point or solid, especially when you take performance in the game fields into account.

JMO.
 
The manufacturers are always looking for the next 'big thing' to promote what will boost sales and make them money. Hollow points fall into that category.

People have tried various forms of hollow point all the way back to the days of the buffalo hunters. They never caught on, for whatever the reasons may be. Then along came SuperVel in the 70s, and all the other manufacturers tried again with a full court press. The rest is history, even though it took ~30 years to work out most of the kinks.

I've never thought that much of hollow points. I've not seen any evidence that they are to be preferred over a good soft point or solid, especially when you take performance in the game fields into account.

JMO.
The only one that I ever wanted was the silvertip and later, the talon, both similar and from Winchester. Both very effective from my experience and observation.
 
"...became a private citizen legally authorized to carry a concealed firearm."
I would respectfully suggest Mr. Boyle re-read his pocket Constitution. The right to keep & bear arms is not a privilege, as his choice of words indicate. We do not ask permission from the government (even though many tyrant-ruled states demand precisely this). The Right to self-preservation and the means to effectuate it are given to us by our Creator, just as it is with all of our other Rights.
Rights From GOD Not Govt PNG.png
 
The dreaded Winchester silver tip, Treasury load, was designed to expend all the energy inside the human body. It was a 110 to grain bullet +P+ 38 spl, that was wonderful.

Then the libs began to complain and now it's history. It did too much damage to the internal organs and was cruel and nasty to the criminals.
You can still find it...
 

Meaning and Origins of “God Blesses Those Whose Cause Is Just”​

The phrase you’ve quoted is a variation of a well‑known proverb: “Thrice is he armed that hath his quarrel just, but four times he who gets his blow in first” — attributed to Josh Billings in His Sayings (1865) Lib QuotesLib Quotes. The idea is that a person who has a just cause is “armed” three times (by justice, righteousness, and moral authority), and if they also strike first, that’s a fourth advantage.

Biblical and Moral Context​

While the exact wording is not from the Bible, the sentiment aligns with scriptural teaching that God blesses the righteous and those who pursue justice. In the Old Testament, the “just” are those who walk in God’s law, and they are described as blessed — for example, Psalm 1:1‑3 and Proverbs 10:6 link righteousness with prosperity and divine favor Bible HubBible Hub. Deuteronomy 16:20 commands, “Pursue justice, and justice alone,” tying moral rightness to God’s blessing.

In the New Testament, the Beatitudes (Matthew 5:6) bless those who hunger and thirst for righteousness, and Romans 1:17 affirms that “the righteous will live by faith” Bible HubBible Hub. These passages show that in Christian thought, justice is not only a moral good but a source of divine blessing.

The “Thrice Blessed” Idea​

The phrase “thrice is he armed” echoes the biblical theme of threefold blessing — God’s favor, moral standing, and spiritual strength — and is reinforced in the Plymouth Brethren Archive’s discussion of “Thrice Blessed” as a reflection of God’s mercy and favor toward the righteous Plymouth Brethren ArchivePlymouth Brethren Archive.

Summary​

  • Origin: Popularized by Josh Billings (1865) as a proverb about justice and timing Lib QuotesLib Quotes.
  • Biblical parallel: Scripture consistently teaches that God blesses those who live justly and pursue righteousness Bible HubBible Hub+1.
  • Moral lesson: Justice is both a moral and spiritual advantage; acting with righteousness and seizing the moment in defense of that cause is seen as doubly or triply blessed.
In short, the saying blends a witty proverb with a deep biblical truth: God’s blessing is tied to justice, and those who act justly — and act first — are especially favored.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CEW
Over penetration, well back in the old days I would wait for my targets to line up, I could nail both with one shot. Wait that was with a shotgun... Aw different ammo as was it steel or lead? Oh Dear is there a law against that? A slug could mean the end of the world as we know it...

Back on point or that is the point, pick the round and charge for the intended use and I don't know what to say about idiots making policy when they don't know a right from a permission slip as previously stated MN Militia. Can't carry hollow points but the Po-Po is allowed or required to. Why would be the question, watch when or if the logic dawns on their Libtarded mind, with the so you want me to accidentally send a round through someone else or the wall...

As I look for what ammo to load, consideration over velocity and purpose. The 380's get the wonky Phillips head screwdriver tips and the 223 Rems get soft point or poly tipped (does that count as a hollow point). Everything else, everything in-between.

Of course I live in free state and the only controversy is over FRTs...
 
The hollow point ammunition was developed to expand as much of its energy upon contact with any surface, not just humans. For example, when used in a home defense situation, a missed shot through drywall will dissipate most of its energy on contact, reducing the chance of the bullet continuing on and striking the wrong person.
 
I decided to go for max penetration. I use ball. Underwood makes some outstanding powerful ammo, but lots of their cut bullets don't feed reliably. Here are some of the Uline penetration tests I did for various loads a few years ago.

Too long to post all at once. Look for the rest in another post. Test procedure: 12 inches of Uline catalogs were stacked and put in a cardboard box to test bullet penetration. Catalogs changed every 2 to 6 shots. 1911 fans, .45 has terrible penetration.

.32 H&R Magnum Black Hills 85 grain JHP 1-7/8" barrel Ruger LCR snubnose.
Penetration:15/16"

.32 H&R Magnum Hornady FTX Critical Defense 80 grain JHP w/plastic 1-7/8" barrel Ruger LCR snubnose.
Penetration:1-1/8"

*.327 Federal Magnum

.327 Federal Magnum Underwood 95 grain Xtreme Defender solid copper 1500fps 1-7/8" barrel Ruger LCR snubnose.
Penetration:1-1/2"
Notes:Would not eject, jammed in cylinder. Gun cylinder was clean.

.327 Federal Magnum Federal Hydra-Shok 85 grain JHP w/pin 1-7/8" barrel Ruger LCR snubnose.
Penetration:1-1/4"
Notes:Ejected fine.

*.380 Auto

.380 Auto Underwood 68 grain Xtreme Defender solid copper 1300fps 2-3/4" barrel S&W Bodyguard 380
Penetration:1-7/16"

.380 Auto Underwood 100 grain Hard Cast Flat Nose Black Cherry Coated 975fps 2-3/4" barrel S&W Bodyguard 380
Penetration:15/16"

.380 Auto Remington 95 grain FMJ 2-3/4" barrel S&W Bodyguard 380
Penetration:13/16"

.380 Auto Federal 90 grain Hydra-Shok JHP w/pin 2-3/4" barrel S&W Bodyguard 380
Penetration:7/8"

.380 Auto PPU 94 grain FMJ 2-3/4" barrel S&W Bodyguard 380
Penetration:1"

.380 Auto S&W 84 grain JHP (blunt RN HP) 2-3/4" barrel S&W Bodyguard 380
Penetration:1-1/4"
Notes: 1990's vintage - Bangor Punta era.

.380 Auto Cor Bon 90 grain 1050 fps JHP 2-3/4" barrel S&W Bodyguard 380
Penetration:15/16"
Notes: Dirty

.380 Auto Ruger ARX 56 grains composite 2-3/4" barrel S&W Bodyguard 380
Penetration:1"

.380 Auto Hornady 90 grain XTP JHP 2-3/4" barrel S&W Bodyguard 380
Penetration:13/16"

.380 Auto Hornady FTX Critical Defense 90 grain JHP w/plastic 2-3/4" barrel S&W Bodyguard 380
Penetration:7/8"

.380 Auto Winchester 95 grain PDX1 Defender Bonded JHP 2-3/4" barrel S&W Bodyguard 380
Penetration:1-1/8"

*.38 Special- 2-1/8 inch snubnose barrel.

.38 Special Underwood 100 grain Xtreme Defender Solid copper 1200fps 2-1/8" barrel S&W snubnose
Penetration:1"

.38 Special Remington 130 grain FMJ 2-1/8" barrel S&W snubnose
Penetration:3/4"

.38 Special PPU 158 grains Lead RN 2-1/8" barrel S&W snubnose
Penetration:3/4"
Notes:Privi Partizan, Serbia. Dirty load.

.38 Special Federal 130 grain FMJ 2-1/8" barrel S&W snubnose
Penetration:1"

.38 Special Hornady 158 grain XTP JHP 800 fps 2-1/8" barrel S&W snubnose
Penetration:3/4"+

.38 Special Hornady 125 grain XTP JHP 900 fps 2-1/8" barrel S&W snubnose
Penetration:3/4"

.38 Special Federal Hydra-Shok JHP w/pin (Grains?) 2-1/8" barrel S&W snubnose
Penetration:3/4"

.38 Special Winchester Kinetic HE 110 grains 2-1/8" barrel S&W snubnose
Penetration:15/16"

.38 Special Hornady 110 grains FTX JHP w/plastic tip 2-1/8" barrel S&W snubnose
Penetration:1-1/8"

.38 Special Hornady Pink Label 90 grains FTX Critical Defense JHP 1200 fps w/plastic tip 2-1/8" barrel S&W snubnose
Penetration:3/4"+
Penetration:13/16"
Notes:Tested 2x

.38 Special (?) grains? R-P Remington-Peters Lead HP 2-1/8" barrel S&W snubnose
Penetration:3/4 inch.
Notes:Dirty

*.38 Special - 4 inch barrel.

.38 Special Underwood 100 grain Xtreme Defender Solid copper 1200fps 4" barrel Ruger GP100
Penetration:1-1/8"

.38 Special 130 grain Federal FMJ 4" barrel Ruger GP100
Penetration:1-1/8"

.38 Special 158 grain PPU / Privi Partizan Lead RN 4" barrel Ruger GP100
Penetration:3/4"
Notes:Dirty

.38 Special 130 grain R-P Remington Peters FMJ Flat Tip 4" barrel Ruger GP100
Penetration:1-3/16"

.38 Special 158 grain Magtech reloaded Lead RN 4" barrel Ruger GP100
Penetration:5/8"

.38 Special 110 grain Winchester Kinetic HE JHP 950 fps 4" barrel Ruger GP100
Penetration:1-3/8"
Penetration:1-3/8"
Notes:Tested 2x

.38 Special 150 grain Winchester Lead RN 4" barrel Ruger GP100
Penetration:7/8"

.38 Special 125 grain Hornady XTP JHP 900 fps 4" barrel Ruger GP100
Penetration:7/8"

.38 Special 158 grain Hornady XTP JHP 800 fps 4" barrel Ruger GP100
Penetration:7/8"

.38 Special 90 grain (Pink Label / Women's load) Hornady SPCL FTX w/plastic 4" barrel Ruger GP100
Penetration:7/8"
Penetration:7/8"
Notes:Tested 2x

*.38 Special +P - 4 inch barrel.

.38 Special Underwood 100 grain Xtreme Defender Solid copper 1300fps 4" barrel Ruger GP100
Penetration:1-13/16"
Penetration:1-7/8"
Notes:Tested 2x

*.357 Magnum 2-1/8: barrel

.357 Magnum Underwood 120 grain Xtreme Hunter solid copper 1700 fps 2-1/8" barrel S&W snubnose
Penetration:1-7/8"
Notes:Hurt hand

.357 Hornady grains (?) Critical Defense w/plastic 2-1/8" barrel S&W snubnose
Penetration:1-3/8"

.357 125 grain Winchester Elite PDX1 Defender Bonded JHP 2-1/8" barrel S&W snubnose
Penetration:1-3/16"

*.357 Magnum 4" barrel

.357 Magnum Underwood Xtreme Hunter solid copper 1700 fps 4" barrel Ruger GP100
Penetration:2-1/4"

.357 Hornady grains (?) Critical Defense w/plastic 4" barrel Ruger GP100
Penetration:1-7/16"

.357 125 grain Winchester Elite PDX1 Defender Bonded JHP 4" barrel Ruger GP100
Penetration:1-7/16"

*9mm Luger 4.9" barrel Beretta 92 FS

9mm Luger 90 grains Underwood XT Defender solid copper 1400 fps 4.9" barrel Beretta 92 FS
Penetration:2-1/8"
Penetration:2"
Notes:Tested 2x

9mm Luger 68 grains Underwood XT Defender Platinum coated solid copper 1700 fps 4.9" barrel Beretta 92 FS
Penetration:2-1/8"

9mm Luger 115 grains Blazer FMJ 4.9" barrel Beretta 92 FS
Penetration:1-3/16"

9mm Luger 135 grains Hornady Critical Duty FlexLock HP w/plastic 4.9" barrel Beretta 92 FS
Penetration:15/16"

9mm Luger 115 grains PMC Bronze FMJ 4.9" barrel Beretta 92 FS
Penetration:2"
Penetration:2"
Notes:Tested 2x

9mm Luger 115 grains Kinetic HE JHP Winchester 4.9" barrel Beretta 92 FS
Penetration:1-13/16"

9mm Luger 124 grains Winchester FMJ Target 4.9" barrel Beretta 92 FS
Penetration:1-1/16"

9mm Luger 115 grains Remington R-P FMJ 4.9" barrel Beretta 92 FS
Penetration:1-5/8"

9mm Luger+P 115 grains Barnes TAC XPD all copper HP coated 4.9" barrel Beretta 92 FS
Penetration:15/16"

9mm Luger 100 grains Team Never Quit JAG Frangible 1300 fps HP 4.9" barrel Beretta 92 FS
Penetration:1-7/8"

9mm Luger 115 grains Herter's nylon jacket solid bullet aluminum case 4.9" barrel Beretta 92 FS
Penetration:2"

9mm Luger 65 grains Ruger ARX copper/ polymer blend composite bullets 1620 fps 4.9" barrel Beretta 92 FS
Penetration:1-13/16"

9mm Luger 115 grains Sig Sauer V-Crown JHP 1185 fps 4.9" barrel Beretta 92 FS
Penetration:1-9/16"

9mm Luger Hornady Critical Defense JHP w/plastic 1620 fps 4.9" barrel Beretta 92 FS
Penetration:1-3/8"

*9mm Luger +P 4.9" barrel Beretta 92 FS

9mm Luger 68 grains Underwood XT Defender Platinum coated solid copper 1800 fps 4.9" barrel Beretta 92 FS
Penetration:2-1/2"

*9mm Luger 16.25" barrel S&W M&P FPC

9mm Luger 68 grains Underwood XT Defender Platinum coated solid copper 1700 fps 16.25" barrel S&W M&P FPC
Penetration:2-5/8"

9mm Luger 90 grains Underwood XT Defender solid copper 1400 fps 16.25" barrel S&W M&P FPC
Penetration:2-1/16"

9mm Luger 115 grains Blazer FMJ 16.25" barrel S&W M&P FPC
Penetration:1-7/16"

9mm Luger 124 grains Winchester FMJ Target single packed 16.25" barrel S&W M&P FPC
Penetration:1-1/4"
Notes:Dirty

9mm Luger 115 grains Winchester FMJ Target bulk packed 16.25" barrel S&W M&P FPC
Penetration:1-3/8"
Notes:Dirty

9mm Luger 115 grains Remington R-P FMJ 16.25" barrel S&W M&P FPC
Penetration:2"
Penetration:2-1/8"
Penetration:2-1/16"
Notes: Tested 3X / slightly dirty

9mm Luger 115 grains Sig Sauer V-Crown JHP 1185 fps 16.25" barrel S&W M&P FPC
Penetration:2-1/8"

9mm Luger 100 grains Team Never Quit JAG Frangible 1300 fps grains 16.25" barrel S&W M&P FPC
Penetration:2-1/8

*9mm Luger +P 16.25" barrel S&W M&P FPC

9mm Luger +P 68 grains Underwood XT Defender Platinum coated solid copper 1800 fps 16.25" barrel S&W M&P FPC
Penetration:3-1/8"
Penetration:3-1/16"
Penetration:3-1/16"
Notes:Tested 3X

*9mm Luger +P+ 16.25" barrel S&W M&P FPC

9mm Luger +P+ 90 grains Underwood XT Defender solid copper 1550 fps 16.25" barrel S&W M&P FPC
Penetration:2-3/8"

9mm Luger +P+ 90 grains Underwood XT Defender Platinum coated solid copper 1550 fps 16.25" barrel S&W M&P FPC
Penetration:2-7/8"

*.45 Auto 4.5" barrel FN FNP-45

.45 230 grains Federal FMJ 4.5" barrel FN FNP-45
Penetration:1"

.45 118 grains Ruger ARX copper/ polymer blend composite bullets 1307fps 4.5" barrel FN FNP-45
Penetration:1-1/2"

*5.7x28mm 16" barrel FN PS90

5.7x28mm 40 grains Federal American Eagle FMJ 16" barrel FN PS90
Penetration:2-7/8"

5.7x28mm 40 grains FN Hornady V-Max 16" barrel FN PS90
Penetration:1-7/8"

*.5.56mm NATO 10" barrel Sig P556 Pistol

5.56mm NATO IMI (Israel) 55 grain FMJ 10 inch barrel Sig P556 pistol
Penetration:6-1/4"
Notes:Contact shot, no flash hider. Blew up the box! Debris in a 6' circle.

5.56mm NATO IMI (Israel) 55 grain FMJ 10 inch barrel Sig P556 pistol with Gemtech suppressor.
Penetration:4-1/4"
Notes:Comparison .223 with 10" barrel Sig P556 Pistol = 4-1/16" penetration.

*.5.56mm NATO 16" barrel AR-15 Stag Arms

5.56mm NATO IMI (Israel) 55 grain FMJ 16" barrel AR-15 Stag Arms with Gemtech suppressor.
Penetration: 4-7/8"

5.56mm Lake City Green Tip M866 62 grain 16" barrel AR-15 Stag Arms with Gemtech suppressor.
Penetration: 4-7/8"

*7.62×51mm & .308 16.5 inch barrel AR-10

7.62×51mm Lake City M80 NATO 149 grain FMJ dated 2020 16.5 inch barrel AR-10
Penetration:6-1/8"
Notes:Bullet held together but was curved like a banana and heavily flattened longitudinally.

.308 Winchester Power Point 150 grain JSP 2820 FPS 16.5 inch barrel AR-10
Penetration:3-7/8"
Notes:Bullet disintegrated into a small piece of lead.

End of tests.
 
Here are the rest of the Uline tests...

Notes to the Uline penetration tests that are missing from the rimfire and centerfire tests: The penetration for most calibers were measured to the rear of the bullet with a 1/8-inch steel probe through the hole. So, the deformed bullet length should be added to all results, except the following. The 5.56, .308 & 7.62 were dug out and calculated as best as possible. Catalogs were changed before their destruction affected future tests.

*.22 Rimfire - snubnose 2" barrel.

.22 CB Short 710fps S&W snubnose 2" barrel.
Penetration:1/4"

.22 L.R. Stinger 1640fps S&W snubnose 2" barrel.
Penetration:3/4"

.22 .22 L.R. Remington Golden Bullet HP S&W snubnose 2" barrel.
Penetration:1/2"+

.22 L.R. Target Lead RN 1200 fps S&W snubnose 2" barrel.
Penetration:7/8"
Penetration:7/8"
Notes:Tested 2x



*.22 Rimfire - 3.5" threaded barrel

.22 CB Short 710fps Walther P22 3.5" threaded barrel.
Penetration:11/16"
Notes:Failed to eject

.22 L.R. Subsonic Walther P22 3.5" threaded barrel.
Penetration:3/4"
Notes:Dirty

.22 L.R. Remington Golden Bullet HP Walther P22 3.5" threaded barrel.
Penetration:5/8"
Penetration:9/16"
Notes:Tested 2x

.22 L.R. Stinger 1640fps Walther P22 3.5" threaded barrel.
Penetration:7/8"



*.22 Rimfire - 18" barrel.

.22 L.R. Stinger Savage Mark II rifle 18" barrel.
Penetration:1-1/2"

.22 L.R. Remington Golden Bullet HP Savage Mark II rifle 18" barrel.
Penetration:1-1/4"
Penetration:1-1/4"
Notes:Tested 2x.

.22 L.R. Target Lead RN 1200 fps Savage Mark II rifle 18" barrel.
Penetration:#1 1-3/8"
Penetration:#2 1-3/8"
Notes:Tested 2x



*.22 WMR - 1-1/2" barrel

.22 WMR 40 grain HP North American Arms derringer 1-1/2" barrel.
Penetration:1-3/16"



*.32 S&W Remington

.32 S&W Remington Lead RN 88 grain 1-7/8" barrel Ruger LCR snubnose.
Penetration:5/8"



*.32 H&R Magnum

.32 H&R Magnum Black Hills 90 grain Lead SWC 1-7/8" barrel Ruger LCR snubnose.
Penetration:3/4"

.32 H&R Magnum Black Hills 85 grain JHP 1-7/8" barrel Ruger LCR snubnose.
Penetration:15/16"
 
Last edited:
I noticed the poly case/interceptor/arx or even the NOVX brand defensive bullets were not mentioned. They have very unique and desirable qualities and they’re not classified as hollow points either. What areyour opinions on these two rounds?
 
I am not a fan of ball ammo in any caliber... It over penetrates. That's not to say that ball didn't do it job, as it just punched a hole clean through the intended target, but it bodes badly for the neighbor just beyond. Also, under pressure we may not be as good a shot as we think. If there is a chance you could be shooting in an urban environment, some mechanism is needed and/or some consideration to caliber dynamics should be considered to reign-in a projectiles brute-force.
 
I am not a fan of ball ammo in any caliber... It over penetrates. That's not to say that ball didn't do it job, as it just punched a hole clean through the intended target, but it bodes badly for the neighbor just beyond. Also, under pressure we may not be as good a shot as we think. If there is a chance you could be shooting in an urban environment, some mechanism is needed and/or some consideration to caliber dynamics should be considered to reign-in a projectiles brute-force.
In the smaller calibers, they penetrate better. 55 years ago, I thought the .32 ACP Winchester Silvertip hollow point was a good idea for the cartridge. Today, I realize the Lehigh-type, solid-copper, projectile and Flat Point FMJ projectiles perform better in self-defense scenarios.

Enough said.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CEW
In the smaller calibers, they penetrate better. 55 years ago, I thought the .32 ACP Winchester Silvertip hollow point was a good idea for the cartridge. Today, I realize the Lehigh-type, solid-copper, projectile and Flat Point FMJ projectiles perform better in self-defense scenarios.

Enough said.
for smaller calibers... I would not argue with that, but I might add that shot placement become even more important as caliber size decreases. I had a friend many years ago who was accidentally shot with a .22LR when the friend standing next to him discharged his rifle (you know how teenagers are). The bullet lodged in his liver. Not a good spot to get hit as the liver tends to hemorrhage blood at the slightest injury. He had the good sense to lay down and apply pressure while the others retrieved their truck instead of attempting to walk out. He lived. He said it felt like someone slapped him on the belly. He felt very little pain. Similarly, those who used the 5.7x28 in the service came to understanding that one shot won't do it with that round. Most kept those FNs on full auto because the knew they would have to zip a stitch or the attacker would not stop. Small calibers have their limitation.
 
In the smaller calibers, they penetrate better. 55 years ago, I thought the .32 ACP Winchester Silvertip hollow point was a good idea for the cartridge. Today, I realize the Lehigh-type, solid-copper, projectile and Flat Point FMJ projectiles perform better in self-defense scenarios.

Enough said.
Why “Enough said,” I wonder…
 
  • Helpful
Reactions: CEW
Back
Top