testtest

9's, are they really all that

with a saturation of 9x19/9mm luger's and companies finding new ways to entice buyers why are so many other wonderful cartridges left out! with some of the new designs i'm liking what's out there, but it's just a vanilla boring ole nothing like glock and 1911 designs...............nothing really new! a splash of colors, 2-tones, multi-whatever colors they think people will buy, but it's just a plain jane 9! chatting with our resident kimber lover @SimonRL about some 45's i wish other brands would follow suit. i have 1 of their 10's and trying to decide on which 1 of 3 kimber's (or 2) i'm wanting next? not many offer 40s/w let alone 357sig, so what does that leave................9's and 45's mostly 🤬 . same could be said for the other cartridges, but now i'm stuck with obtaining more 45-70 handguns:unsure::rolleyes:. as much as the division 77 from wilson looks soooooooooo gooood i can't get myself to buy 1 because it's a 9:(. now if it was in 357sig, 40s/w, 10mm and/or 45acp i'd be getting a few. i search and search and search for something different other than a yeet cannon that only @10mmLife & @Belt Fed would buy as i'll leave that too them! how much glock perfection can someone take.................i'm at 9 and would be at 10 if i could confirm numbers on a gen3 31c to add to the 20c and 21c. as much as i like glock, i have no further interests in them as thay're all the same regardless of gen #'s. 1911's.................nothing new in the last 100+ years, but i managed to but 7😭 (probably going to be an 8 and 9 or 10 in there soon🤷‍♂️). i might think different about all that's been mentioned if and i mean a big IF i'd ever sell/trade any! i have 1 question.................WWB7 do (what would @BET7 do)........................probably buy the whole store or factory🤣🤣🤣......................i guess i'm going down the revolver hole on handguns..............i'm about out on AR limitations and BA's ARn't as interesting as AR's and semi-auto handguns to me (ymmv). here's a thought on how certain cartridges could be cheaper like 9x19's................offer more or a better selection in 10's or something other than vanilla! firearms per cartridge are roughly the same price per manufacturer within the same line so it's not that a 9x19 is cheaper, it just holds more rounds in the clip:rolleyes: as the smart firearm peeps say🤣. if i'm going to be stuck with X amout of rounds per clip, then i'd want the most power i could find to defend myself and family!

 
I own three 9mm pistols a Kel-Tec P-11, a Bersa TPR9, and a Girsan MC P35. That's all I need. If I wanted anything more, it would be a Bersa TPR9X (a TPR9 with a 5" barrel.)
I don't need anything that's going to cost an arm and a leg. I was pleasantly surprised at Bersa's quality. So much so that I have two Thunder .380's and my personal favorite, a Thunder .32.

Everything else is just "gilding the lily".
 
TEXASforLIFE that was a fun 'adventure in reading' and I wish I had the vim, vigor & vitality to author a post like that! I love the little 9MM poodle shooter boolits and their superior numbers in the clip. I still enjoy the big ole' june-bugesque .45's and the Devils' own reasonable choice in-between, the .40 Short & Wimpy.

I get where you're coming from wanting the 'most power you can find' to defend you and yours. I have fond memories of my Dad watering the front lawn in the evenings before they moved from the declining neighborhood to the new house. He watered with one hand and in the other gripped a paper bag with his thumb. The bag held a 7.5" Super Blackhawk stuffed full of 240 grain magnum soft points. He had only to release his thumb for the bag to fall off of the hog-leg. He had probably a baker's dozen of more appropriate defensive handguns in the house but, hey.... we're not here to judge the departed!
 
When you think about it, how many handgun cartridges are there? If we are talking rimless, the number shrinks.

Aside from these options, designing a handgun to fire a rifle cartridge is pretty much limited to revolvers (or a derringer type, if you are so inclined). Then the practical question is why? A short barrel won't burn the powder charge completely so you get a tremendous fireball. Recoil will prove unpleasant for a large percentage of shooters, thereby limiting their appeal.

9mm dominates the market because that is what sells. The popularity of the cartridge then benefits from economy of scale due to that popularity. A simple comparison of the the price of 9mm v. .380 illustrates that point readily.

Unless manufacturers see sufficient demand to justify a handgun chambered in a new or different cartridge, they won't take the risk. They are in business to turn a profit, after all. The .30 Super Carry is a recent example of a risk that failed to provide return.
 
When you think about it, how many handgun cartridges are there? If we are talking rimless, the number shrinks.

Aside from these options, designing a handgun to fire a rifle cartridge is pretty much limited to revolvers (or a derringer type, if you are so inclined). Then the practical question is why? A short barrel won't burn the powder charge completely so you get a tremendous fireball. Recoil will prove unpleasant for a large percentage of shooters, thereby limiting their appeal.

9mm dominates the market because that is what sells. The popularity of the cartridge then benefits from economy of scale due to that popularity. A simple comparison of the the price of 9mm v. .380 illustrates that point readily.

Unless manufacturers see sufficient demand to justify a handgun chambered in a new or different cartridge, they won't take the risk. They are in business to turn a profit, after all. The .30 Super Carry is a recent example of a risk that failed to provide return.
Sad, but true.
 
Ammo cost and availability is a huge factor. Own a few 9's and can afford to practice with them regularly .20 to .25 per round. Will occasionally take out the others but .45 costing .50 a round and .380, .45 a round....it gets expensive.

Also,having to buy in bulk to get the lowest prices isn't always possible.
which is where (in my opinion) it works out to have a reloading set up..

you start off by buying new ammo, save up as much as you can of that, then reload after that..

buy new when you can...or buy NEW brass in bulk.

primers, powder one might already have........and bullet prices well, depends on what you want.
 
with a saturation of 9x19/9mm luger's and companies finding new ways to entice buyers why are so many other wonderful cartridges left out! with some of the new designs i'm liking what's out there, but it's just a vanilla boring ole nothing like glock and 1911 designs...............nothing really new! a splash of colors, 2-tones, multi-whatever colors they think people will buy, but it's just a plain jane 9! chatting with our resident kimber lover @SimonRL about some 45's i wish other brands would follow suit. i have 1 of their 10's and trying to decide on which 1 of 3 kimber's (or 2) i'm wanting next? not many offer 40s/w let alone 357sig, so what does that leave................9's and 45's mostly 🤬 . same could be said for the other cartridges, but now i'm stuck with obtaining more 45-70 handguns:unsure::rolleyes:. as much as the division 77 from wilson looks soooooooooo gooood i can't get myself to buy 1 because it's a 9:(. now if it was in 357sig, 40s/w, 10mm and/or 45acp i'd be getting a few. i search and search and search for something different other than a yeet cannon that only @10mmLife & @Belt Fed would buy as i'll leave that too them! how much glock perfection can someone take.................i'm at 9 and would be at 10 if i could confirm numbers on a gen3 31c to add to the 20c and 21c. as much as i like glock, i have no further interests in them as thay're all the same regardless of gen #'s. 1911's.................nothing new in the last 100+ years, but i managed to but 7😭 (probably going to be an 8 and 9 or 10 in there soon🤷‍♂️). i might think different about all that's been mentioned if and i mean a big IF i'd ever sell/trade any! i have 1 question.................WWB7 do (what would @BET7 do)........................probably buy the whole store or factory🤣🤣🤣......................i guess i'm going down the revolver hole on handguns..............i'm about out on AR limitations and BA's ARn't as interesting as AR's and semi-auto handguns to me (ymmv). here's a thought on how certain cartridges could be cheaper like 9x19's................offer more or a better selection in 10's or something other than vanilla! firearms per cartridge are roughly the same price per manufacturer within the same line so it's not that a 9x19 is cheaper, it just holds more rounds in the clip:rolleyes: as the smart firearm peeps say🤣. if i'm going to be stuck with X amout of rounds per clip, then i'd want the most power i could find to defend myself and family!

amout…..amout……
IMG_5835.gif
 
Last edited:
I never have particularly liked the 9mm cartridge. Although I do have a bunch of guns chambered for it. Truth is that I own them because I liked the gun and that's just the caliber it came in.
I can see the appeal. Fairly low recoil and easy to shoot. Even a complete novice can handle it. Ammo is everywhere and fairly reasonably price. And so many to choose from. Its a buyer's market.
If the S ever should HTF, no doubt I'll be carrying a 9mm simply because it'll be the easiest ammo to scrounge. The stuff is everywhere.
I do have other cartridges I like better for self defense, But I won't balk at a 9mm. I get's the job done.
 
For those that find the 9mm lacking in a 9mm-sized pistol they can root around GB to find a .45 GAP or a .40 S&W.


For the .45GAP both Glock (G37) and SA (XD) chambered them in pistols but both went away very fast, so you might find a good deal on slightly used pistols.

Ammo is still available albeit at elevated prices.


I won't go into the 40 S&W since there's more options there.
 
Ammo cost and availability is a huge factor. Own a few 9's and can afford to practice with them regularly .20 to .25 per round. Will occasionally take out the others but .45 costing .50 a round and .380, .45 a round....it gets expensive.

Also,having to buy in bulk to get the lowest prices isn't always possible.
I'm a .45 guy through & through. It is my EDC choice and very likely the first firearm I grab should I be forced to defend my shack.

I did buy a 9 for two reasons you stated, vast availability of ammo, and cost thereof.

Otherwise, .45 all the way.
 
Back
Top