testtest

Resident defends family from intruder, no charges to be filed.

trader

Hellcat
Cochise county, Saint David. He found a man trying to get inside and eliminated the threat. Castle Doctrine referenced.


From the article - "Investigators carefully evaluated the physical evidence, medical examiner's findings, and applicable Arizona laws governing self-defense, defense of others, and protection of an occupied residence. These considerations included legal protections commonly referred to as California’s identified Castle Doctrine, which recognizes an individual's right to defend themselves and others against certain unlawful threats within their home. The findings were reviewed in consultation with the Cochise County Attorney's Office, and the decision not to pursue criminal charges was reached after consideration of the available evidence and applicable law."

This is Arizona. What about your county/State?
 
Montana law justifies self-defense, property protection, and defense of others under Title 45, Chapter 3 of the Montana Code Annotated.

Key Self-Defense & Force Laws in Montana
    • Defense of Person: You may use reasonable force against another person when you reasonably believe it is necessary to protect yourself from imminent unlawful force (MCA § 45-3-102).
    • Deadly Force: Lethal force is justified only if you reasonably believe it is necessary to prevent imminent death or serious bodily harm to yourself or someone else, or to prevent the commission of a forcible felony (MCA § 45-3-102, MCA § 45-3-103).
    • Stand Your Ground & Duty to Retreat: Montana is a "stand your ground" state and does not impose a legal duty to retreat or flee before using reasonable or deadly force in public or in your home (MCA § 45-3-110).
    • Home Defense (Castle Doctrine): Using force—including deadly force—is justified to prevent unlawful entry into an occupied structure if it is necessary to prevent an assault or a forcible felony (MCA § 45-3-103).
    • Defense of Property: Non-deadly force is allowed to protect real or personal property from trespass or theft, but deadly force is not permitted solely to protect property unless a forcible felony is involved (MCA § 45-3-104). A forcible felony involves physical force or violence against a person, meaning you cannot legally use lethal force merely to stop property theft, vandalism, or trespass where no human life or safety is threatened.
    • Initial Aggressors: If you start or escalate a confrontation, you generally cannot claim self-defense unless you clearly communicate withdrawal or exhaust all reasonable means of escape (State v. Fredericks, 2024 MT 226).
    • Burden of Proof: Once you present evidence that your use of force was justified, the prosecution must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the force was not legally justified.
 
I was not clear enough about the event. This happened in Cochise county, a predominantly rural area and the town is heavily religious and conservative.

Had the exact thing occurred in Pima county or perhaps Maricopa county, the homeowner could be facing a trial.

Pima county attorney Conover is famous for not prosecuting drug offenses and what she calls misdemeanor criminals. She has recently rehired two attys previously fired out of the same office for misconduct.

Now my earlier comment should make more sense...
 
Guess I would never move to Arizona.

Arizona residents face the same challenges many states do. The major metropolitan areas drive elections and policy for the entire state. These areas are becoming increasingly leftist because their residents are predominantly low information voters who don't have a background based on traditional American values.

Geographically, the majority of the state is pretty conservative. Maricopa and Pima counties have been transformed by immigrants from other states that have fled to Arizona to escape the results of leftist policies. Those same immigrants bring their ideology with them because they fail to see the society they are fleeing is created by leftist policy.

Then those people will complain that Arizona is becoming too much like California. Incredibly, they will then vote for the liberals because they promise to fix the problems their policies create. Texas has headed down that road.

The promise of free stuff and rampant virtue signaling are too powerful for the weak minded.
 
Cochise county, Saint David. He found a man trying to get inside and eliminated the threat. Castle Doctrine referenced.



This is Arizona. What about your county/State?
i seriously don't care what my state laws are....

if i am outside, doing yard work, or inside my house and ANYONE comes onto my property threatening me, or family....

its'......."shoot first, i was stopping a threat"
 
Back
Top