testtest

Julie Golob: Springfield Echelon 4.0FC Review

Hi,

Julie is great. The whole Echelon line is great. My 4.5F Comp really trips my trigger, makes my pistol pop, and has great bang-for-your-buck when bundled with a 'gear up' promotion. (See what I did there?) :LOL:

Thank you for your indulgence,

BassCliff
 
Julie’s article actually reinforced something I discovered while customizing my own Echelon 4.0C Comp: finding what works for you.

Out of the box, the Echelon has a very good trigger.

My goal was never to build a race gun or chase the lightest trigger possible. I wanted to create a highly defined trigger while maintaining reliability.

Specifically, I wanted:
  • Minimal take-up
  • A defined wall
  • A crisp, predictable break
  • Reduced reset travel
  • A pronounced reset
After researching the available options, I realized that the Tyrant I.T.T.S. and Powder River Precision (PRP) products seemed to solve different parts of what I was looking for.

I ultimately built a hybrid “Franken-trigger” using:
  • Tyrant I.T.T.S. trigger shoe
  • PRP spring kit
  • PRP sear
Because reliability was one of my priorities, I intentionally retained the factory striker spring.

Neither Tyrant nor PRP specifically recommends this exact combination of parts, but my thought process was that both systems are designed around the Echelon platform and factory component interfaces, so I believed the combination would likely be mechanically compatible.

Fortunately, that assumption proved to be correct.

For me, this wound up being the perfect trigger.

The biggest improvements were minimal take-up, a defined wall, a crisp break, and a pronounced reset.

For anyone interested: the pull weight decreased from approximately 4.5 lbs to 3.25 lbs, although that was never my primary objective.

What surprised me most was that this project wasn’t really about modifying the pistol at all. It was about removing the firearm as a variable so I could expose and improve my own fundamentals.

I discovered that some bad habits I had developed, particularly anticipation, were still my responsibility to correct, but they had likely been reinforced over time by adapting to the characteristics of the factory trigger.

Now that the trigger is more predictable, I can actually see my own skill on the target and work on improving it.

Ultimately, this project wasn’t about buying accuracy. It was about creating a more predictable firearm that would allow me to identify and improve my own fundamentals.

Current setup:
  • Tyrant I.T.T.S.
  • PRP Spring Kit (retaining the factory striker spring)
  • PRP Sear
  • Apex Tactical Stainless Steel Guide Rod and Cap
  • NDZ Performance ISMI -10% recoil spring
  • Holosun HE407C-GR X2
So far, reliability with the reduced recoil spring has been excellent, and I haven’t experienced any issues returning to battery.
 
Last edited:
Hi,

Julie’s article actually reinforced something I discovered while customizing my own Echelon 4.0C Comp: finding what works for you.

Out of the box, the Echelon has a very good trigger.

My goal was never to build a race gun or chase the lightest trigger possible. I wanted to create a highly defined trigger while maintaining reliability.

Specifically, I wanted:
  • Minimal take-up
  • A defined wall
  • A crisp, predictable break
  • Reduced reset travel
  • A pronounced reset
After researching the available options, I realized that the Tyrant I.T.T.S. and Powder River Precision (PRP) products seemed to solve different parts of what I was looking for.

I ultimately built a hybrid “Franken-trigger” using:
  • Tyrant I.T.T.S. trigger shoe
  • PRP spring kit
  • PRP sear
Because reliability was one of my priorities, I intentionally retained the factory striker spring.

Neither Tyrant nor PRP specifically recommends this exact combination of parts, but my thought process was that both systems are designed around the Echelon platform and factory component interfaces, so I believed the combination would likely be mechanically compatible.

Fortunately, that assumption proved to be correct.

For me, this wound up being the perfect trigger.

The biggest improvements were minimal take-up, a defined wall, a crisp break, and a pronounced reset.

For anyone interested: the pull weight decreased from approximately 4.5 lbs to 3.25 lbs, although that was never my primary objective.

What surprised me most was that this project wasn’t really about modifying the pistol at all. It was about removing the firearm as a variable so I could expose and improve my own fundamentals.

I discovered that some bad habits I had developed, particularly anticipation, were still my responsibility to correct, but they had likely been reinforced over time by adapting to the characteristics of the factory trigger.

Now that the trigger is more predictable, I can actually see my own skill on the target and work on improving it.

Ultimately, this project wasn’t about buying accuracy. It was about creating a more predictable firearm that would allow me to identify and improve my own fundamentals.

Current setup:
  • Tyrant I.T.T.S.
  • PRP Spring Kit (retaining the factory striker spring)
  • PRP Sear
  • Apex Tactical Stainless Steel Guide Rod and Cap
  • NDZ Performance ISMI -10% recoil spring
  • Holosun HE407C-GR X2
So far, reliability with the reduced recoil spring has been excellent, and I haven’t experienced any issues returning to battery.

That was very informative. Thanks for sharing. Did your setup take a lot of trial and error? Did you do the work yourself? I've been considering a PRP kit for a couple of my units.

It seems you've been here for a while but this is your first post. Welcome to the community, thanks for joining us.

Thank you for your indulgence,

BassCliff
 
Hi,



That was very informative. Thanks for sharing. Did your setup take a lot of trial and error? Did you do the work yourself? I've been considering a PRP kit for a couple of my units.

It seems you've been here for a while but this is your first post. Welcome to the community, thanks for joining us.

Thank you for your indulgence,

BassCliff
Thank you, BassCliff! I appreciate the warm welcome.

Actually, there wasn’t much trial and error at all because I spent a considerable amount of time researching before purchasing anything.

I had very specific goals in mind and noticed that the Tyrant and PRP products each seemed to solve different parts of what I was looking for, so I decided to build a hybrid setup around those goals.

I didn’t perform the work myself. I had my local gunsmith install everything, and I specifically asked him to retain the factory striker spring because I was concerned about light primer strikes and already knew the factory spring was reliable.

Out of curiosity, what are your goals for the PRP kits?

That’s ultimately how I approached this project. I identified my goals first and then selected components that appeared to solve different parts of the problem.

From my research, I expected the Tyrant I.T.T.S. to primarily improve take-up and reset characteristics.

I expected the PRP sear to help refine the break, while the PRP spring kit would contribute to smoothing things out.

Reduced pull weight was simply a side effect for me.

I should also add that I didn’t independently test each component one at a time, so I can’t definitively say that one specific improvement came from one specific part.

Jenni
 
Last edited:
Hi,

Out of curiosity, what are your goals for the PRP kits?

Generally, I don't have a problem with factory triggers. If I haven't used a particular unit for a while, it may take a few rounds to get reacquainted.

But I have one unit that has a long takeup through a bowl of oatmeal, until it hits a wall of marshmallow, a little bit of creep like an over-ripe banana, then breaks like a soggy noodle. Reset? Ha!

Because of its reputation here, I was going to drop in a PRP (extreme) kit just to lighten it up a bit and get it to act like a real trigger.


Thank you for your indulgence,

BassCliff
 
Hi,



Generally, I don't have a problem with factory triggers. If I haven't used a particular unit for a while, it may take a few rounds to get reacquainted.

But I have one unit that has a long takeup through a bowl of oatmeal, until it hits a wall of marshmallow, a little bit of creep like an over-ripe banana, then breaks like a soggy noodle. Reset? Ha!

Because of its reputation here, I was going to drop in a PRP (extreme) kit just to lighten it up a bit and get it to act like a real trigger.


Thank you for your indulgence,

BassCliff
🤣 That’s actually a fantastic description.

I completely understand what you mean because that’s essentially what sent me down this rabbit hole in the first place.

My trigger philosophy eventually became: I don’t want a conversation left open to interpretation with the trigger. I want a committed relationship. 😄

Place finger on trigger —> wall —> break —> reset —> repeat.

I don’t mind effort, but I definitely don’t like uncertainty.

That particular unit you described sounds like exactly the kind of situation where first identifying what you want to improve would be helpful before selecting parts.

Jenni
 
Well i really don’t do the echelon line. The only one I had I just pawned off to a friend. Yes I said I pawned it off to a friend because he really liked it (yes all laws were applied for the transfer out of state).
 
Hi,

My Echelon triggers are fine. I have an older XD45 Mod2 Tactical that has mush for a trigger. That's the first one I'll replace. Then we'll go from there. ;)


Thank you for your indulgence,

BassCliff
 
Hi,

My Echelon triggers are fine. I have an older XD45 Mod2 Tactical that has mush for a trigger. That's the first one I'll replace. Then we'll go from there. ;)


Thank you for your indulgence,

BassCliff
BassCliff,
I’m definitely a Springfield girl! I carried XD9 Mod.1 and Mod.2 (both Subcompact) and had a Mod.3 when I was a firearms instructor at a range in Houston.

I love the XD series but they don’t have the Mod.3 or Mod.4 in subcompact.

I’m not a huge fan of the Hellcat line or the XDS/XDE because they’re very snappy, though they are more easily concealable.

I traded in my beloved XD’s for the Echelon because I had a great deal on it and because it’s optics ready and ported.

Still loving it!

What triggers are you considering for your XD45?

Jenni
 
Well i really don’t do the echelon line. The only one I had I just pawned off to a friend. Yes I said I pawned it off to a friend because he really liked it (yes all laws were applied for the transfer out of state).
JSimon78,
Which Echelon did you have, and what was it that you didn’t like about it?

Jenni
 
Hi Jenni,

BassCliff,
I’m definitely a Springfield girl! I carried XD9 Mod.1 and Mod.2 (both Subcompact) and had a Mod.3 when I was a firearms instructor at a range in Houston.

I love the XD series but they don’t have the Mod.3 or Mod.4 in subcompact.

I’m not a huge fan of the Hellcat line or the XDS/XDE because they’re very snappy, though they are more easily concealable.

I traded in my beloved XD’s for the Echelon because I had a great deal on it and because it’s optics ready and ported.

Still loving it!

What triggers are you considering for your XD45?

Jenni

I appreciate the conversation. I am also a Springfield fanboy. ;) About half of my modest collection are SA products, XD9 4" Service, XD9 Mod.3, XDM Elite Precision, Echelon 4.5F Comp, Echelon 5.28 Threaded Barrel, just to name a few. I don't do well with subcompacts, anything less than a 4" barrel. I have the tactical girth to conceal the larger units. :p

I was considering a drop-in trigger kit from Powder River Precision for my XD45 Mod2 Tactical. I took it to the range yesterday for a little more practice and, while I can shoot it pretty well, it just takes so much concentration that it's distracting. (I don't like to think.) :LOL:

20260615_165905_resized.jpg


I'd rather be able to shoot it from muscle memory. The current trigger is SO MUCH different than all my other triggers. None of my triggers are mushy like this one.

You should know that I've been seriously practicing, training, and collecting for only about six years. I'm an "old noob" at this stuff. We had a few long guns for hunting when I was a kid but then, life, ya know? Now I'm hoping I'll be able to teach the grandkids when they are a little older. The community here has been very helpful to this old noob.


Thank you for your indulgence,

BassCliff
 
Back
Top