The issue is quite likely the Critical Defects.
The rubber “brake pad” in the nose is known to cause failures to feed in several different pistols.
Additionally, handguns have their idiosyncrasies; just because one handgun will feed it, even if it’s the consecutive serial number to yours, is no guarantee yours will…there’s nothing wrong with your pistol.
I’d try a different JHP. Bet it feeds just fine.
(ETA—nice autocorrect typo, with “Defects” for “Defense”…I’ll just let it be)
I never would have suspected it was a typo. That is a perfect name for it.